In many retail sectors, there appear to be two clear-cut market leaders, and many people have a favorite.
You may prefer Lowe’s over Home Depot, or Sam’s Club over Costco.
The same logic applies to food. Some people are diehard Hostess fans, while others ride or die with Little Debbie.
In some areas, these choices can be polarizing and divisive. One person may be all into the Big Mac, while their partner likes the Whopper a lot.
The most polarizing battle, however, may be the choice between Coca-Cola and Pepsi.
Both companies have public claims of being better than the other, and each has restaurants and other partners such as theme parks, movie theaters, and arenas under exclusive contracts.
When a brand converts from Coke to Pepsi or vice versa, it’s going to upset some customers, and that’s what Costco has done with its food court. Warehouse Club has switched from PepsiCo brands to Coca-Cola products.
Since both Coke and Pepsi have fan bases, the switch may upset some customers.
I experienced a similar reaction last year when I switched cruise lines from Pepsi products to Coca-Cola while sailing on Carnival Celebration. After the list was exhausted, Coke fans searched for the remaining Coke products, while Pepsi drinkers searched for the last Mountain Dew and Pepsi, highlighting how emotionally charged soda loyalty can be.
Costco made the switch in late 2025 and completed swapping Pepsi products for Coca-Cola brands in early 2026.
It’s not something Costco has commented on widely, but CEO Ron Vakris addressed it during a question-and-answer session at the retailer’s annual meeting.
More retail:
“Yes, that’s right,” said Vakhris. “This summer, we will begin transitioning our food court fountain business to Coca-Cola.”
Costco had an exclusive deal with Pepsi since 2013.
“Costco switched to Pepsi in 2013 as a cost-saving measure, to keep the price of its famous hot dog and soda combo at $1.50. At the time, Pepsi was offering Walmart a better price deal that Costco couldn’t match. When Costco asked Coke to set the same price, Coco refused to set Coke the same price. Stores for an entire month,” Costco Insider reported.
Costco hasn’t shared why it’s back, but Costco Insider, who is not affiliated with the company, shared his thoughts on the change.
“While the original switch was a cost-saving measure, the return to Coke products is likely driven by customer preference and a renewed commitment to Coke quality and the partnership with Costco,” it shared.
The question of Coke vs. Pepsi, however, is a trigger for some people
“Coke vs. Pepsi has always been a cultural dividing line, like Yankees vs. Red Sox or Apple vs. PC,” Manhattan-based psychiatrist Jonathan Alpert said, The Independent reported. “People attach memories, family traditions, and even a sense of who they are to the brand. So when Costco suddenly took the side, it generated a much bigger reaction than soda.”
Related: Costco vs. Sam’s Club: Comparing memberships, prices and benefits
Coca-Cola’s market leadership: Coca-Cola Classic has consistently dominated the US soda market, with a share of approx 19.2% Carbonated soft drink sales, while PepsiCo shares close to 8.3 percentAccording to Visual Capitalist data.
Consumer preference poll: A citizen science survey of more than 15,000 American adults found that About 52% of Americans expressed a favorable preference for Cokecompared with 40% for PepsiCitizen Science reported, indicating widespread popular support for Coca-Cola.
Furthermore, 19% of those surveyed have one Adverse view of cokeWhile 29% felt the same about Pepsi.
Given Coca-Cola’s large market share and strong consumer preference, Costco’s food court switch can reduce friction for members, helping to maintain traffic and satisfaction at its most visible touchpoints.
Related: USDA: Costco has a serious problem with its $4.99 chicken
This story was originally published by TheStreet on January 15, 2026, where it first appeared in the Retail section. Add TheStreet as a preferred source by clicking here.
Many people work hard to build a retirement nest egg. But then, once their careers…
It may seem like we're back in familiar territory - the Duke of Sussex is…
Did you get enough protein today? Granger Wootz/Getty Images/Tetra Images RFRELATED: RFK Jr. Opens Up…
Jan 17 (Reuters) - Twelve days into the U.S. capture of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro,…
When you make a purchase through links in our articles, Future and its syndication partners…
In a new study, researchers matched five people infected with the flu in a hotel…