Elon Musk has ignited the discourse once again; This time most people treat the basics of financial security: retirement savings.
In a recent episode of the Moonshot with Peter Diamandis podcast, Business Insider reports, the CEO of Tesla and SpaceX argued that the traditional idea of saving for retirement may become “irrelevant” in the next decade or two due to advances in artificial intelligence (AI), robotics and energy technologies. He claims that this will usher in a new era of abundance.
Kasturi paints a bold, but imaginative, picture: where machines do most of the work, goods and services are plentiful and cheap, health care and education are freely accessible, and a so-called “universal high income” ensures that everyone’s basic needs are met. In that future, Musk says, worries about taking money away for retirement “don’t count.” But before you side with the world’s richest entrepreneur and ditch your 401(k), there’s an important reality check to consider.
Musk’s thesis rests on an extreme view of technological transformation; One in which AI, robotics and other innovations increase productivity so dramatically that scarcity – money, work and the economic power to save – will effectively disappear.
In such a world, he argues, traditional retirement planning may lose its relevance.
That is an optimistic and highly speculative view of the future. Musk said he envisions the transition could be “bumpy,” potentially sparking social unrest and even a financial crisis as traditional work becomes less necessary (1).
It’s important to note that Musk isn’t offering personal finance advice in the traditional sense. He is describing a theoretical future economy. Yet his influence means many people could interpret his comments as a green light to stop saving altogether — especially for younger workers still in the early stages of building financial security.
Read more: The average net worth of Americans is a staggering $620,654. But it makes almost no sense. Here’s the number to calculate (and how to make it skyrocket)
Unlike Musk, most Americans don’t have a billion-dollar safety net in case the future doesn’t unfold as predicted. For many, retirement savings are far from irrelevant. In fact, they are critically inadequate.
According to the Federal Reserve’s Survey of Consumer Finances (2), nearly half of American households had no retirement savings at all by 2022, and only about a quarter had more than $100,000 saved.
AARP further reports that 1 in 5 Americans 50 and older have no retirement savings, and more than half feel they do not have enough saved for a secure retirement (3). Many workers feel behind on retirement planning, CNBC reports, admitting they’re not saving enough or started too late (4).
Many financial planners recommend saving enough to replace a substantial portion of pre-retirement income—often translating to hundreds of thousands or more than a million dollars—depending on lifestyle and your unique needs and expenses (4).
These benchmarks are beyond the current savings of most Americans. Against this background, advice suggesting that saving for retirement won’t matter soon can be very misleading if taken at face value.
A psychological risk like Musk’s statement: People may take them as permission to save or stop participating in employer-matched plans — habits that actually threaten long-term security.
For workers with inflation-driven expenses, student loans, housing and health care costs, and uncertain access to employer retirement plans, retirement can already feel distant and intangible. The message that retirement plans may eventually become obsolete may make it easier to delay starting or increasing retirement contributions.
And while technology has historically increased productivity and created new economic opportunities, there’s no guarantee that these advances will automatically translate into abundance for everyone, let alone on a timeline that matches Musk’s predictions.
Financial professionals generally agree that retirement planning remains essential under today’s economic climate. No strong, widely supported policy or economic structure currently exists that guarantees universal income or the elimination of scarcity anytime soon.
Until such mechanisms are in place, individuals are still responsible for constructing their own safety nets. Instead of treating Musk’s comments as a personal finance strategy, look at them as a reminder that the future of work and income can change. That said, it’s best to plan based on what you know now, not what might happen.
This means:
-
Contributing consistently to retirement accounts, especially when employers match contributions
-
Build an emergency fund
-
Regularly review and adjust savings targets, and
-
Staying informed about broader economic and technological trends
In other words: prepare for the world you live in today, while being prepared to adapt if seismic economic changes arrive.
We rely only on vetted sources and reliable third-party reporting. For details, see our editorial ethics and guidelines.
Business Insider (1); United States Facts (2); AARP (3); CNBC (4)
This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.
